By RTE News - 03.12.2024 - [Amirul Arif Bin Mohd Yunos] - [IRELAND]
A child psychiatrist who groomed and sexually abused a teenage girl leaving her with "painful and grave trauma" has been jailed for eight and a half years.
Amirul Arif Bin Mohd Yunos, 38, with an address in Hollystown, Dublin 15, was working as a child psychiatrist in a Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services (CAMHS) centre in Clonskeagh, Co Dublin, at the time of his offending in 2023, Dublin Circuit Criminal Court heard.
The victim was not formally his patient. Yunos was known to her parents, who had asked him to engage with their daughter who was experiencing mental health difficulties on an ad-hoc basis.
She was 15 when most of the incidents occurred between May and June 2023 and 16 when the final incident occurred in September 2023.
Yunos pleaded guilty to six counts of engaging in a sexual act with a child under 17, one count of sexual exploitation of a child and one of meeting a child for the purpose of sexual exploitation.
He has no previous convictions and has been in custody in relation to this offending for the last 14 months. The court heard that the victim and her parents want Yunos to be named but wish to maintain their anonymity.
The now 17-year-old is experiencing significant and ongoing mental distress, the court was told. The abuse started with inappropriate touching, before escalating to penetration. The offences took place at a number of locations including a car, his home, her home and his workplace.
'Painful and grave trauma' - victim impact statement
In a victim impact statement read to the court by prosecuting counsel, Derek Cooney BL, the girl said the abuse has left her with "painful and grave trauma".
She said she blamed herself, felt she "induced" the abuse and "deserved it".
"He made me believe the hugs I needed during a tough time led to sexual abuse," she said, later adding that she felt she had made a "good man" sexually abuse her.
She said she wanted to tell his wife, but he told her not to.
She will "forever carry doubt towards the intentions of people who want to help me", she said.
The man "took something from me that will never return" and she now fears men and living. She said her schoolwork has suffered and she has "lost a chunk" of her young life which can never be returned.
The girl said the abuse has had an "agonising" impact on her emotionally and psychologically.
Her 15-year-old self "never wanted this", the girl added.
"She wanted to get better. She asked for that help. In hindsight, that 15-year-old got handed a lifelong sentence of unwanted trauma."
Judge's Sentence
Imposing sentence today, Judge Orla Crowe said this was a "deeply serious matter".
She noted that the victim was "not a patient per se" of Yunos's, rather her parents had asked him for help.
The judge noted that Yunos initially engaged in therapy sessions with the girl at her home, but over time the nature of these sessions changed.
The judge said the victim impact statement highlighted the "very grave" and ongoing effects on the girl. She said these effects "should have been apparent to this offender, given his professional insight".
The judge said Yunos had breached the trust of the girl "who was groomed by him, then abused" and the trust of her parents, which was an aggravating factor.
She said there were other issues in relation to Yunos's "professional standing, insight and training".
"He had qualified in this country and had been training in the area of psychology. He would have and ought to have been better placed than most," the judge said, adding that Yunos would have been expected to have a "greater insight" into the potential for trauma to be caused.
"And there was trauma caused to this complainant," Judge Crowe said.
She said the aggravating factors also included the grooming behaviour, his professional and social standing, the impact on the victim and the escalating nature of the offending.
"This is offending that simply has to be marked with imposition of a significant custodial sentence," Judge Crowe said, setting a headline sentence of 12 years.
She noted that the mitigation included an early guilty plea, lack of previous convictions, and his expressions of remorse.
Judge Crowe said the court had reviewed testimonials, a letter of apology from Yunos and a psychological report submitted to the court on behalf of Yunos.
She noted the psychological report stated he had a "promising career" but his offending will prevent him from working in this field in Ireland in the future.
The judge said the court was "struck" by a section of the psychological report which noted that Yunos would have been expected to have a greater insight into the damage this offending could cause due to his expertise.
The judge said Yunos is "very fortunate his community and wife have stood by him", referring to the testimonials submitted to the court.
She imposed a sentence of eight years and six months, backdated to when he went into custody. Addressing the girl's parents who were present in court, Judge Crowe extended the court's best wishes to them for her future. "There is no wrongdoing on her part in relation to the matter," she added. If you have been affected by any of the issues raised in this article and were abused in state run medical and health facilities, you can contact Dignity4Patients, whose helpline is open Monday to Thursday 10am to 4pm.
Dignity4Patients Commentary:- While many in positions of oversight might argue that patient sexual abuse is uncommon, they often underestimate the long-lasting trauma these incidents can cause. Implementing proactive #RiskManagement and stringent #Supervision is essential to prevent #SexualAbuse and ensure a secure healthcare environment for everyone. #SafeHealthcare #PatientProtection